When a longstanding Executive Director announces their departure, the board’s first instinct is often to start recruiting. There is a job description to update, a search committee to assemble, and a reassuring thought: if we find the right person, the organization will be fine. 

Today, this scenario is increasingly common. A combination of factors across the nonprofit industry have created a silent wave of retirements, resignations or industry exits, creating a leadership gap felt from the local humane society to large hospital foundations and beyond. Suddenly board members find themselves in unfamiliar territory: hiring and leadership transitions.  

But the work ahead is much bigger than filling a vacancy. 

Leadership transitions unfold over months and sometimes years, reaching into every part of an organization. A new ED inherits relationships, expectations, unwritten practices, and decisions that may have rested with one person for decades. An appointment date does not mark the end of that transition. 

The board may also be navigating unfamiliar territory. When an ED has served for twenty years, none of the current directors may have experience hiring for the role. Even those who regularly recruit in their own workplaces may have limited understanding of what leading this particular nonprofit requires. Preparing to hire calls for reflection, learning, and sometimes professional development before recruitment begins. 

Yet the pressure to maintain services and reassure stakeholders can push boards straight into a search before they understand what is at stake. 

Those stakes include organizational knowledge, mission continuity, staff retention, and funding relationships. 

Consider a community organization whose departing ED has managed its largest funding relationship for fifteen years. The grant agreement is documented, but the history behind it is not: concerns raised during the last renewal, informal commitments, and why the funder remains invested. Without a deliberate handover, the successor inherits responsibility without the knowledge needed to sustain that relationship. 

Inside the organization, staff wonder whether programs will continue, roles will change, or valued flexibility will survive. If trusted managers leave, the organization loses more knowledge precisely when it needs it most. Meanwhile, funders may delay commitments until the direction becomes clearer. These risks reinforce one another: funding uncertainty unsettles staff, departures disrupt services, and disruptions weaken community confidence. 

With so much at stake, boards understandably seek reassurance in their next hire. They want someone who can “hit the ground running.” 

That urgency can narrow attention to immediate problems. An organization facing a funding shortfall may prioritize fundraising above everything else, overlooking the people leadership and strategic judgment needed for its longer-term health. Someone promising quick solutions may feel safer than someone asking difficult questions about capacity or governance, even when those questions demonstrate a stronger understanding of the job. 

Directors can also default to familiar measures of success from their own professional backgrounds, often in the corporate sector. A polished presentation or recognizable employer becomes reassuring, while experience navigating community accountability and constrained resources receives less attention. 

Internal candidates face another obstacle. A respected manager may understand the organization but have limited exposure to fundraising or board relations. Directors conclude they need someone more seasoned, although those gaps might have been addressed through development opportunities years earlier. By the time recruitment begins, there is little room to recover that lost preparation. 

There is another assumption worth questioning: that plenty of capable people are waiting to become EDs. 

The work can be deeply meaningful. It can also be hard and lonely. Leaders are expected to raise money, support staff, manage finances, maintain partnerships, and work effectively with a volunteer board—sometimes with little administrative support. 

Consider a program director watching their ED answer emails on vacation, cover staffing gaps, and spend evenings preparing board reports. Encouraged to consider executive leadership, they hesitate. They believe in the mission. They also want a life outside work. 

Their hesitation deserves attention. When investment in systems, staff development, and management capacity has been deferred, an exceptional ED may be expected to compensate. A successor inherits the same constraints that exhausted their predecessor. Making the role sustainable is part of attracting people to it. 

Boards can reduce these risks before anyone announces a departure.  

Oftentimes the lack of succession planning stems from a reluctance to introduce the topic at board meetings because it may signal an impending departure even if that is not the case. Boards or current EDs could start by asking: if the ED were suddenly unavailable, who could lead temporarily, with what authority and support? Document the answer in a short emergency succession plan, including signing authority, access to essential records, and communication responsibilities. 

Then make preparation part of everyday governance. Keep funding deadlines, key relationships, and operating procedures current. Introduce a second staff member to major funders and partners. Give emerging leaders opportunities to manage budgets, present to the board, and lead projects—with time and support to learn. 

Review the ED’s workload and address expectations that depend on constant availability. As a transition approaches, clarify future priorities, prepare directors to assess candidates, and budget for handover and onboarding. Set realistic goals for the first year, supported by regular board-chair check-ins and mentoring or coaching. 

For organizations in a position to consider formal planning processes, making it a part of strategic planning, engaging staff and board in organizational health assessments and documenting standard operating procedures is a worthwhile investment for a smoother transition down the road.  

With more than 70% of nonprofit executive directors planning to leave their role in the next 5 years, the moment calls for leadership. Preparing for it is a responsibility boards can take up today. 

Is your organization ready? Take our leadership transition readiness assessment and get a personalized report. Not sure where to start? Book a complimentary People Strategy Call with our team today. 

Mariya Yurukova, MBA, CFRE, leads Charity Search Group Canada and advises nonprofit boards on executive recruitment, succession planning, and leadership transitions. With more than 20 years of nonprofit experience and 175+ leadership placements, she understands the demands of leading mission-driven organizations. CSG Canada offers executive search, strategic and succession planning to help small and medium-sized nonprofits prepare for what comes next. 

The views expressed in this article are the author’s alone and do not necessarily represent those of CharityVillage.com or any other individual or entity with whom the authors or website may be affiliated. CharityVillage.com is not liable for any content that may be considered offensive, inappropriate, defamatory, or inaccurate or in breach of third-party rights of privacy, copyright, or trademark.